Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Alejandro Piad Morffis's avatar

Loved it. I have this undeveloped idea that AI text generators, by virtue of being only trained on text, can at most generate what some philosophers would call "analytic knowledge", facts that are true only due to the relationship between words. Synthetic knowledge, in turn, requires accessing the experiential world. And that's where the real value comes from. I can share my experiences with you, and make you kinda experience it as well.

Expand full comment
Robert J. Rei's avatar

I have spent a small amount of time with two of these objects under discussion, Chat GPT, and Google's BARD. I used them knowing full well that the "responses" I get back to my queries are not natural or organically generated. With natural organic origin communications such as between two human beings first and foremost, from my perspective, to consider is the epistemological model of the two minds involved in any language interaction, the second consideration is understanding that all human expression of knowledge creation conveyed via some mode of communication ie. whether written, spoken, or signed (ASL etc.) take place within the larger context of the open system of reality, as opposed to the all too often erroneous assumption of communication taking place as always being confined to a closed system model, or empirically reducible.

With these two thoughts in mind I approach my games with the AI text generators with an intentional objective of eliciting something that is as close to a subjective response as is possible. I discovered that with one session I was able to essentially create an appearance of having gained a response that acknowledged the difference between an objective answer as opposed to a subjective answer.

It was interesting to observe that the written response I received once I made it clear to the program that it was permissible to provide a subjective answer the wording of the response was almost as if the AI text generator was pleased to be able to do so.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts